Dear A.S.S. Editor

I refer to the article “Additional S$100m a year to help town councils maintain, replace lifts: MND” (Channel NewsAsia, Feb 2). It states that “Taken together, the additional funding will double MND’s existing funding support to town councils – under the annual Service and Conservancy Charge operating grants and quarterly Goods and Services Tax subvention – which amounted to around S$120 million in FY15/16, according to the ministry.”

50% matching grant? As to “The funding will consist of a lift maintenance grant of S$600 per lift owned and maintained by the town councils, which is expected to cost the Government an additional S$13 million a year, as well as match 50 per cent of their quarterly contributions to the Lift Replacement Fund that will become mandatory for town councils from Apr1 this year.

14% S & C C increase is about $100m? The lift replacement fund, meanwhile, is expected to cost the Government more than S$50 million in the coming year” – does it mean that the minimum of 14 per cent of the S & C C that town councils will now be required to set aside in the sinking fund for lifts is about $100 million ($50 million x 2)? If so, then we can try to estimate the total that all the town councils collect in a year – $714 million ($100 million divided by 0.14).

About $9 increase? So, with about 900,000 HDB households – does it mean that the expected average increase in S & C C per household due to this new lift fund is about $111 a year ($100 million divided by 900,000) or $9 a month? As I understand that the average monthly S & C C is about $50 – does it mean that it may translate into an average increase of a whopping about 18 per cent ($9 divided by $50)?

Debate in Parliament? Instead of just announcing the numbers like “minimum of 14 per cent” and “more than $100 million more grants” – shouldn’t there be a debate in Parliament as to what it actually means for Singaporean HDB households, like I have tried my best to estimate above?

No F1 = No S & C C increase? By the way, since there has been speculation in the media that F1 may not continue – why not use the as I understand it – $150 million a year to fund lifts, so that S & C C may not need to be increased?

Leong Sze Hian

A.S.S. Contributor

Check Also

Supervisor Showed Up At Worker’s House To See If His Mother Was Really Sick

This guy came to my door to ask my injured mother to show her MC. He didn't believe I had to take care of her. The company then terminated me after that!